Ikani Josiah Obaka Okwori Abel Ibrahim Ojo Gabriel Ogala Samuel Vol 8(12), 302-306 DOI- http://dx.doi.org/10.5455/ijlr.20180721060420
The study was conducted to evaluate the adaptability and performance of 12 improved forage legume species. The results showed significant (P<0.05) differences among the legume species for plant height. At 4 weeks after sowing (WAS), plant height ranged from 7.76 cm for Desmodium intortum to 43.10 cm for Mucuna pruriens (black seeded) in the field and results in the pot experiment were similar. Plant height at 16 WAS ranged from 104.95 cm to 398.56 cm for Gliricidia sepium and Lablab purpureus, respectively. Calcium content ranged from 0.77% in Cajanus cajan to 1.16% in Gliricidia sepium and Centrosema pascuorum. Phosphorus content ranged from 0.33% to 2.27% in Centrosema pascuorum and Aeschynomene americanum, respectively while potassium ranged from -0.32% to 0.27% for Gliricidia sepium and Cajanus cajan, respectively. It is recommended that Cajanus cajan, Lablab purpureus, Centrosema pascuorum, Centrosema pubescens and Mucuna pruriens (White and black seeded) be adopted by livestock farmers and pasture agronomists to establish ranches and produce seeds.
Keywords : Forage Height Legumes Minerals
Forage and fodder crops are central to the development of Nigeria’s livestock industry. This feed resource, which consists mainly of grasses, legumes, browses, and cereal crop residues vary widely and are spread across the major agro-ecological zones of the country (Shiawoya and Tsado, 2011). Improved pastures produce more dry matter of high nutritive value and lead to greater animal productivity than do native pastures (Nuru, 1996). The need for improved legume forage species into the southern guinea savanna ecology cannot be overemphasized since the poor quality natural grassland largely contributes to the poor animal performance. Given the prevailing economic conditions with high cost of other feed sources which are generally too high to be recommended for widespread use, Nigeria will have to rely heavily on intensive use of pastures to improve the nutritional status of livestock. Abayomi et al. (2001) have evaluated legume cover crops but this study has a wider scope of forage legume species for performance evaluation. This study was therefore designed with the aim of introducing and determining the growth performance and mineral composition of 12 tropical forage legume species for establishment.
Materials and Methods
The study was conducted from May to November, in 2015 to 2016 cropping seasons at the pasture field of the Livestock Teaching and Research Farm, College of Animal Science of the University of Agriculture, Makurdi, Nigeria. Makurdi is located on latitude 07o 41’ N, longitude 08o 37’E and altitude 106.4 m (NIMET, 2016). Seeds of twelve (12) forage legume species: (Cajanus cajan (L) Millsp, Stylosanthes hamata (Verano), Gliricidia sepium (Gliricidia), Centrosema pubescens (Centro), Mucuna pruriens-white seeded, Alysicarpus vaginalis, Leucaena leucocephala, Desmodium intortum, Lablab purpureus (Rongai), Mucuna pruriens-black seeded, Aeschynomene americanum and Centrosema pascuorum (Centro) were obtained from feeds and Nutrition Research Programme of National Animal Production Research Institute (NAPRI), Shika, Zaria were used for the study.
The experimental land was well prepared to allow for good seed-to-soil contact which is essential to maintain adequate moisture near the seeds necessary for germination. Out of the twelve (12) forage legume seeds only Mucuna pruriens and Lablab purpureus were not scarified, seeds were harvested from the mature fruits which are usually viable for more than two years. Others were scarified using methods appropriate for each species to break seed dormancy before sowing. The twelve (12) line plots were arranged in a Randomized Complete Block Design (RCBD) with three (3) replicates for the field experiment, while a Completely Randomized Design (CRD) was adopted for the pot experiment and replicated three (3) times. Data generated were subjected to Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) using the Minitab Statistical Software (MSS) (Version 16) (2016) for both field and pot experiments. Means that showed significant differences were subjected to Means Separation using the Fisher’s Least Significant Difference (LSD) of the MSS at the 5 % level of probability (P≤ 0.05). The total plot size was 36m2 with each Unit plot having a size of 0.75m2. The seeds were sown at 0.5cm – 2.5cm depending on the sowing depth specification for each legume species.
Results and Discussion
Increased plant height provides more green area for increased photosynthetic activities and assimilates needed for grain filling (Haseeb-ur-Rehman et al., 2010). The results of the present study have shown that some of the evaluated species have the potential for rapid soil surface coverage. Following crop establishment, Lablab purpureus, Mucuna pruriens (black seeded), Mucuna pruriens (white seeded), Centrosema pubescens and Centrosema pascuorum grew faster which is attributed to their aggressive growth habit unlike other forages studied. These results agree well with the reports of Carsky (1993) in Cameroun and Marilla et al. (1992) in Brazil where ground cover was good with Centrosema pascuorum but were relatively slower in Aeschynomene spp.
Table 1: Mean squares for plant height (cm) at week 4, 8, 12, and 16 after sowing (field experiment)
Source of Variation | DF | (HT-WK 4) | (HT-WK 8) | (HT-WK 12) | (HT-WK 16) |
Replication | 2 | 0.082 | 0.42 | 0.3 | 2815.9 |
Treatment | 11 | 375.809* | 3119.62* | 14844.4* | 35800.6* |
Error | 22 | 0.313 | 1.14 | 0.3 | 2665.6 |
DF: Degree of Freedom; HT: Height; WK: Week
Table 2: Mean squares for plant height (cm) at week 4, 8, 12, and 16 after sowing (pot experiment)
Source of Variation | DF | (HT-WK 4) | (HT-WK 8) | (HT-WK 12) | (HT-WK 16) |
Treatment | 12 | 379.127* | 3119.49* | 14797.5* | 39448* |
Error | 24 | 0.526 | 1.09 | 3.2 | 178 |
DF: Degree of Freedom; HT: Height; WK: Week
Table 3: Mean values of height of forage legume species at 4, 8, 12 and 16 weeks after sowing
Species | 4 Weeks | 8 Weeks | 12 Weeks | 16 Weeks | ||||
Field | Pot | Field | Pot | Field | Pot | Field | Pot | |
Cajanus cajan | 29.73d | 33.23d | 96.41d | 107.22d | 177.77e | 182.69e | 251.92c | 260.42c |
Stylosanthes hamata | 18.68e | 22.35e | 47.65g | 58.23g | 82.10gh | 92.90gh | 116.01de | 126.21de |
Gliricidia sepium | 14.82f | 18.52f | 47.66g | 57.26g | 79.96hi | 88.90hi | 104.95e | 114.15e |
Centrosema pubescens | 11.88h | 16.18h | 100.29c | 112.28c | 243.69a | 253.29a | 336.41b | 347.01b |
Mucuna pruriens (white) | 33.87b | 39.57b | 100.38c | 111.48c | 197.78c | 205.78c | 332.81b | 345.01b |
Alysicarpus vaginalis | 11.68h | 15.28h | 44.51h | 54.65h | 84.98g | 95.68g | 135.86d | 143.80d |
Leucaena leucocephala | 14.32f | 19.84g | 54.09f | 65.16f | 97.87f | 108.07f | 134.83d | 144.02d |
Desmodium intortum | 7.76i | 11.36i | 35.57i | 46.54i | 78.11i | 89.19i | 113.41de | 124.19de |
Lablab purpureus | 32.57c | 38.17c | 131.02a | 139.92a | 245.22a | 255.52a | 398.56a | 409.41a |
Mucuna pruriens (black) | 43.10a | 48.19a | 106.84b | 115.54b | 211.97b | 223.07b | 381.00a | 391.06a |
Aeschynomene americanum | 12.25gh | 16.09gh | 44.42h | 54.92h | 70.98j | 81.58j | 119.52de | 129.41de |
Centrosema pascuorum | 18.95e | 22.31e | 88.87e | 97.27e | 193.86d | 201.96d | 235.03c | 244.13c |
SEM | 0.554 | 0.725 | 1.066 | 1.04 | 0.545 | 1.8 | 51.63 | 13.35 |
a, b, c = Means on the same column with different superscripts are significantly (P<0.05) different; SEM: Standard Error of Mean
Calcium and phosphorus concentrations in the legumes were higher than the suggested critical levels of 0.30% Ca and 0.25% P, necessary to meet ruminant requirements in the tropics (McDowell and Arthington, 2005). The levels of P in this study contrast to the sub-optimal levels of P commonly reported in grasses, legumes and browses of the savannas of Nigeria (Kallah, et al., 1999). The ranges of phosphorus in the forage legumes were 0.31% to 2.27%. These values were higher compared to the NRC recommendation of 0.15% for phosphorus (NRC, 1985). The -0.32% to 0.27% ranges of potassium values in the legumes, were lower than the NRC 0.80% recommendation for potassium (NRC, 1985).
Table 4: Mineral composition (%) at maturity
Species | Ca | Mg | P | Na | K |
Cajanus cajan | 0.77d | 0.075ab | 1.41c | 0.32fg | 0.27a |
Stylosanthes hamata | 0.79d | 0.067bc | 1.85b | 0.45b | -0.25e |
Gliricidia sepium | 1.16a | 0.054e | 0.80e | 0.29g | -0.32e |
Centrosema pubescens | 0.96bc | -0.004f | 0.33g | 0.37cde | 0.082c |
Mucuna pruriens (white) | 0.89c | 0.070abc | 0.63f | 0.35def | 0.27a |
Alysicarpus vaginalis | 1.12a | 0.065bcd | 0.90e | 0.39cd | -0.16d |
Leucaena leucocephala | 0.92c | 0.057de | 0.84e | 0.23h | 0.18b |
Desmodium intortum | 1.01b | 0.077a | 1.10d | 0.33ef | -0.31e |
Lablab purpureus | 1.02b | 0.063cde | 1.76b | 0.54a | -0.32e |
Mucuna pruriens (black) | 0.95bc | 0.072abc | 0.51f | 0.31fg | 0.21ab |
Aeschynomene americanum | 0.96bc | 0.068abc | 2.27a | 0.35def | -0.31e |
Centrosema pascuorum | 1.16a | 0.077a | 0.31g | 0.39c | -0.32e |
SEM | 0.015 | 0.001 | 0.01 | 0.01 | 0.01 |
a, b, c = Means on the same column with different superscripts are significantly (P<0.05) different; SEM: Standard Error of Mean, Ca: calcium, Mg: magnesium, P: phosphorus, Na: sodium, K: potassium
Most forage legume species appeared quite suitable for animal nutrition in terms of contents of Ca, P, Mg, and Na, although rather low in K for production. They appear deficient in potassium compared to animal requirements from the feeding standards of McDowell (1997) but can be supplemented using potassium chloride based salt lick. Grasses deficient in magnesium which animals suffer (grass staggers or tetany) as a result can be supplemented with legumes high in magnesium.
Conclusion and Recommendation
The results obtained in this study revealed that most of the forage legumes species have the potential to supply adequate nutrients for ruminant production. The foliage of the plants contained moderate to high in crude protein at maturity. It is recommended that Cajanus cajan, Lablab purpureus, Centrosema pascuorum, Centrosema pubescens and Mucuna pruriens (White and black seeded) be adopted by livestock farmers and pasture agronomists in this location to establish ranches, fodder banks and produce seeds based on their ability to adapt, establish well and to exceedingly meet nutrient requirements for ruminants.
References